The 10 Best Electric Fireplace Mantels (2020 Buying Guide)

In Buying Guides, Electric Fireplace Buying Guides by James O'KellyLeave a Comment

An electric fireplace with mantel brings together the advantages of an electric fireplace with a stunning looking mantel surround to create a life-like imitation of a real open fireplace in your home.

Electric fireplace mantels differ from other types of electric fireplace because the electric fireplace units already come pre-built into a fireplace mantel. Electric fireplace mantels are therefore versatile pieces of furniture that can be placed in numerous locations around your home.

Electric fireplaces with mantels are a great way to create the atmosphere of having a real fire in your home but without the downsides of having to clean out the fireplace and maintain a fire.

Electric fireplaces don’t have a real flame and so there’s no worry about whether the fire will be producing smoke or keeps going out as a result of an issue. An electric fireplace doesn’t need a chimney or to be vented and so an electric fireplace mantel can be placed against pretty much any wall in your home.

You’ll just need to ensure that you have a standard electrical outlet nearby and you can be using your new electric fireplace with mantle in no time. Simply plug the fireplace in and you can turn on the flames and heater immediately.

Electric fireplaces with mantels are therefore a great investment for your home, and so we’ve put this complete guide to the 10 best electric fireplace mantels you can bight now to help you decide which one is best suited for your needs, and which one will fit best with the décor of your home.

Best Electric Fireplace Mantel

Best Overall

The best overall electric fireplace mantel you can buy right now is the Fieldstone Electric Fireplace Mantel Package.

Its natural stone effect surround and wood mantle, along with realistic flames and a high heat output, makes this fireplace a very popular choice among buyers.

It also has all the other features you’d want in an electric fireplace including a thermostat and remote control.

Find out more about the Fieldstone fireplace and check the latest price here.

Best You Can Buy

The Linwood Electric Fireplace Mantel Package is a range-topping electric fireplace mantel with life-like patented Multi-Fire XD flame effects and a powerful integrated ceramic heater.

Its modern and sophisticated contemporary design along with all the best features including thermostatically controlled heat and a remote control makes this appliance the ultimate electric fireplace mantel package.

See the latest price and find out more about this fireplace here.

Best Budget

If you’re on a budget then the Jasmine Electric Fireplace Mantel Package is the one for you.

Finished in white, is has a clean and sophisticated appearance that has a host of great features including a powerful 1000sqft heater and a remote control, all for a great price.

More out more and see the latest price for the Jasmine fireplace here.

Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Mantels

In summary, the top 10 best electric fireplace mantels are:

  1. Fieldstone
  2. Sussex
  3. Featherston
  4. Eugene
  5. Holbrook
  6. Astoria
  7. Corinth
  8. Denali
  9. Tennyson
  10. Calvert

We’ve gone into much more detail below on each of these best electric fireplaces with mantels to help you decide which is the right one for you.

What To Consider When Buying An Electric Fireplace Mantel

When buying an electric fireplace mantel, not only will you need to consider what features you would like your electric fireplace to come with, but also what type of mantel and surround will best fit with the décor of your home.

The things you therefore need to consider when buying an electric fireplace mantel include:

  • The location for your electric fireplace mantel.
  • The style and color of the mantel and surround.
  • The size of room the fireplace needs to heat.
  • How realistic the flames are.
  • Settings for the flames, such as brightness, speed and color.
  • Other features such as thermostatic heat control and remote control.

Design And Style

Electric fireplace mantels come in a range of designs, from traditional to modern looking, and many come with faux stone effects for the surround with a wooden mantel.

Many electric fireplace mantels can come as plain white for a simplistic but effective look, while others will have a more traditional wooden effect of varying shades.

Our list of best electric fireplace mantels has a range of designs and styles so you’re bound to find one that you’ll love and will blend in perfectly with the other furniture in your home.

Location For Your Electric Fireplace Mantel

Electric fireplace mantels are electric fireplaces that come pre-installed within a fireplace mantel.

You can therefore place these units up against any wall in your home, as long as there is an electrical outlet nearby to plug the electric fireplace into.

All of the fireplaces in our list of best electric fireplace mantels are plug-in rather than direct wire, meaning that you simply need to plug the mantel into one of your home electric outlets and you can use all of the features including the flame effects and heater.

Some electric fireplace mantels are also designed to go in a corner, which can be useful if you’re tight on space.

Flames

Not only will the look and style of the mantel be different, the types and looks of each electric fireplace will be different between each model.

You’ll therefore find that the looks of the logs and the flame effects will differ between the different brands of electric fireplace mantel.

Some electric fireplace mantels will have more realistic flames than others. If you’re looking for the best looking flames from your electric fireplace mantel then look out for flame technology such as 3D SpectraFire Plus found in many ClassicFlame electric fireplace mantels.

Either way, technology has progressed so much that the majority of electric fireplace mantels produce very realistic flames, no matter what the model.

Heater

Every fireplace in our list of best electric fireplace mantels can generate heat, but some are able to heat larger areas of your home than others.

Electric fireplace mantels with a conventional fan heater will typically be able to heat areas up to 400sqft.

If you plan on having your mantel located in a room of your home that is larger than 400sqft in area then look for one that can heat areas up to 1000sqft. These types of electric fireplace mantel typically use infrared heaters or ceramic heaters to be able to heat the larger area.

Electric Fireplace Heater
Our electric fireplace has a fan heater rather then an infrared or ceramic heater

Other Features

If you want to be able to keep your home at a constant temperature then look for an electric fireplace mantel that has thermostatic control. By setting a temperature the fireplace will automatically turn the heater on and off to keep the room at your set temperature.

Another feature to look for is a remote control. If you want to be able to control your fireplace from the comfort of your seat then look for an electric fireplace that comes with a remote.

Optional Extras

Other extras available to order alongside your electric fireplace mantel include:

  • An extended warranty
  • Crackler sound system
  • Fireplace tool set
  • Fireplace screen

Electric fireplace mantels typically come with a 1 year warranty as standard but you can opt for a 2 or 3-year extended warranty when buying your fireplace using the links in this article.

You can also buy a crackler sound system that will generate fire noises to further improve the experience of having a real fire in your home.

Fireplace tool sets and screens are also available as optional extras to help create a more realistic looking fireplace.

Simply add any of these extras to your cart alongside your chose electric fireplace mantel. You’ll find these extras on the website pages of each product.

1. Fieldstone

The Fieldstone Corner Electric Fireplace Mantel Package can be considered as the best electric fireplace mantel on the market right now.

Presented in a beautiful and realistic natural stone veneer surround with wooden mantel, this fireplace really does provide a focal point for any room.

It has a powerful heater that can warm spaces up to 1000sqft in area and has a thermostat integrated so you can keep your room maintained at your desired temperature.

This fireplace comes with patented flame technology to really bring the fires to life. There are also 7 adjustable flame colors that you can change to suit your preference.

This electric fireplace mantel also has a multi-function remote control that you can use to control both the flame effect and heater, and all of their settings.

To see the latest price on the Fieldstone Electric Fireplace Mantel Package and find out more information click here.

Specs

Brand: Dimplex
Style: Stone
Color(s): Gray Stone
BTUs: 5118  
Heating Area: 1000sqft
Dimensions: 54.6 Width 42.6” Height 12.9” Depth

  • LED flame effects with 7 color options
  • Heater with up to 1000sqft heating area
  • Realistic wood effect mantel and stone surround
  • Comes with remote control
  • Flames can be used without heat

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Realistic fire
  • Nice size mantel
  • Beautiful product
  • Real wood mantel
  • Easy to put together
  • Stone is real looking
  • Gives off good heat and heats a small room quickly

You can read all of the reviews on the Fieldstone fireplace right here.

Check the latest price and buy the Fieldstone Electric Fireplace Mantel here.

2. Sussex

The Sussex electric fireplace mantel is a sophisticated and modern looking fireplace than comes in white, and will look great placed up against any wall in your home.

It showcases realistic LED flames in a large firebox with glowing logs and embers for added realism. Use the remote control that comes with the fireplace to adjust how the fire looks in this fireplace.

It also has a thermostatic heater to help keep your home at a constant temperature.

To see the latest price on the Sussex Electric Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: Dimplex
Style: Contemporary
Color(s): White
BTUs: 5120 
Heating Area: 400sqft
Dimensions: 55.19” Width 48.2” Height 17.13” Depth

  • LED realistic flames with inner lit log set
  • Sleek and modern looking white mantel
  • Comes with remote control
  • Flames can be used without heat
  • Heat rooms up to 400sqft
  • Large flames viewing area
  • Includes thermostat controls

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Beautiful flames with calming effect
  • Easy to put together
  • Makes a room feel cozy
  • Brick look firebox looks great
  • Great focal point for a living room

You can read all of the reviews on the Sussex fireplace right here.

Check latest price for the Sussex Electric Fireplace Mantel and buy here.

3. Featherston

The Featherston is another electric fireplace mantel from Dimplex that has a stunning faux stone surround and mantel.

This fireplace has a powerful heater meaning that it will be a great piece of furniture for any large rooms in your home. You’ll also be able to enjoy the usual high quality Dimplex flame effects with a range of flame color to choose from.

The Featherston also comes with a multi-function remote that can be used to control all of the features, and can keep your rooms consistently warm thanks to thermostatic control.

To see the latest price on the Featherston Electric Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: Dimplex
Style:  Stone
Color(s): Gray Stone
BTUs: 5118 
Heating Area: 1000sqft
Dimensions: 61” Width 44” Height 15.56” Depth

  • Realistic stone-look finish
  • Large heating area of 1000sqft
  • 7 color theme LED flames
  • Adjustable logs with patented glow effect
  • Thermostatic control

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Makes even 1000sqft rooms very warm
  • Looks real and built-in
  • Great remote control
  • Comes exactly as advertised
  • Very easy to put together
  • Quiet functioning heater

You can read all of the reviews on the Featherston fireplace right here.

Check latest price and buy the Featherston Electric Fireplace Mantel here.

4. Eugene

The Eugene electric fireplace mantel is another one with a faux stone design but is complemented by a darker wood mantel and base to make it really stand out.

This fireplace also boasts real looking flames thanks to having SpectraFire Plus flame technology, and you can choose from 5 different flame color, brightness and speed settings to find the right look of flames for you.

Coupled with a powerful 1000sqft infrared heater and an accompanying remote control, this electric fireplace mantel is a great purchase for any home.

To see the latest price on the Eugene Electric Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: ClassicFlame
Style: Stone
Color(s): Aged Coffee
BTUs: 5200 
Heating Area: 1000sqft
Dimensions: 45” Width 40” Height 15.5” Depth

  • SpectraFire Plus realistic flame effect technology
  • Heat rooms up to 1000sqft
  • Wood mantel with faux flagstone
  • Logs molded from real burnt wood
  • 5 flame color, brightness and speed settings
  • Enjoy the flames without the heater being on

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Easy to understand instructions
  • Lovely flame
  • Stone very realistic even to touch
  • Good workmanship
  • Well worth the money
  • Under mantel light looks great
  • Noise from heater can be noticeable

You can read all of the reviews on the Eugene fireplace right here.

Check latest price and buy the Eugene Electric Fireplace Mantel here.

5. Holbrook

The Holbrook fireplace comes finished in stunning burnished walnut to fit in with the classic design of your home, and boasts detailed carved moldings to really make this piece of furniture stand out.

Simply plug this fireplace into a nearby electrical outlet and you’re ready to use both the realistic flame effects and 400sqft heater, which can be used to keep your room at a constant temperature thanks to thermostatic control.

The Holbrook also has a remote control included but can only be used to turn the fireplace on and off.

To see the latest price on the Holbrook Electric Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: Dimplex
Style: Traditional
Color(s): Walnut
BTUs: 4695 
Heating Area: 400sqft
Dimensions: 44” Width 43” Height 16.5” Depth

  • Stunning traditional dark mantelpiece design
  • Fan heater with 400sqft heating area
  • Thermostatic control
  • Remote included
  • Natural looking wood finish
  • Realistic glowing embers and flames

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Attractive and lovely piece of furniture
  • Provides good heat
  • Dark and rich wood color
  • No heat control on remote
  • Very easy to assemble
  • Exceeded expectations
  • Adds to ambience of room
  • Extremely well packaged

You can read all of the reviews on the Holbrook fireplace right here.

Check latest price and buy the Holbrook Electric Fireplace Mantel here.

6. Astoria

The Astoria mantel is another fireplace that boasts 3D SpectraFire Plus flame technology so that you can enjoy life-like flames in your home. You can also control the flames to suit your preference thanks to 5 different speed, color and brightness options.

This fireplace will also be able to heat large areas of your home thanks to a powerful 1000sqft infrared heater. A multi-function remote control is also included with this fireplace.

The Astoria electric fireplace mantel showcases elegant design in Empire Cherry color with incredible carvings to bring that Victorian look to your home.

To see the latest price on the Astoria Electric Mantel click here.

Specs

Brand: ClassicFlame
Style: Traditional
Color(s): Empire Cherry
BTUs: 5200 
Heating Area: 1000sqft
Dimensions: 60” Width 45” Height 17” Depth

  • Realistic flames with 3D SpectraFire Plus technology
  • Simply plug into electric outlet to use
  • 5 flame color, speed and brightness options
  • Thermostat included
  • Overheating prevention technology
  • Victorian styling with elaborate carvings

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Beautiful and classic design
  • Fine quality
  • Came exactly as advertised
  • Enough heat to warm room
  • Stunning masterpiece

You can read all of the reviews on the Astoria fireplace right here.

Buy and check latest price for the Astoria Electric Fireplace Mantel here.

7. Corinth

The Corinth is another stunning carved electric fireplace mantel finished in walnut color.

It’s designed to be placed in a corner of your home and also functions as a media center console and TV stand.

Being a ClassicFlame product, it also benefits from the realistic 3D SpectraFire Plus flame technology with numerous flame settings, as well as boasting an infrared heater so that is can heat even the largest of rooms.

To see the latest price on the Corinth Electric Fireplace click here.

Specs

Brand: ClassicFlame
Style: Traditional
Color(s): Burnished Walnut
BTUs: 5200 
Heating Area: 1000sqft
Dimensions: 42” Width 40” Height 15.5” Depth

  • Realistic flames with 3D SpectraFire Plus technology
  • 5 flame color, speed and brightness options
  • Onscreen digital display
  • Can be converted to corner unit
  • Ornate design
  • Overheating technology

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Blends well with other mahogany furniture
  • Flames look close to real
  • Nice and cozy
  • Great features and multiple flame settings
  • Very reasonable price
  • Elegant and functional
  • Excellent workmanship

You can read all of the reviews on the Corinth fireplace right here.

Check latest price for the Corinth Electric Fireplace and buy here.

8. Denali

The Deanli electric fireplace mantel is much like the Eugene fireplace but comes in a more of a grey color for the faux stone effect on the fireplace surround. It also boasts a dark pine mantel and base for added contrasting colors and effect.

The Deanli is another ClassicFlame fireplace meaning you have powerful infrared heater at your disposal alongside realistic flames thanks to 3D SpectraFire Plus technology.

A multi-function remote control and thermostat rounds off the Denali as a great electric fireplace mantel.

To see the latest price on the Denali Electric Fireplace Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: ClassicFlame
Style: Stone
Color(s): Brushed Dark Pine
BTUs: 5200 
Heating Area: 1000sqft
Dimensions: 40” Width 39” Height 11.5” Depth

  • 3D SpectraFire Plus flame technology for added realism
  • Blue and amber flame effects
  • Digital thermostat
  • Rustic faux stone façade
  • Brushed dark pine mantel shelf
  • Up to 1000sqft of heating

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Extremely nice looking
  • 10 minutes to set up
  • Realistic looking flame
  • Well worth the price
  • Heats even the largest of rooms
  • Easy to operate

You can read all of the reviews on the Denali fireplace right here.

Check latest price and buy the Denali Electric Fireplace Mantel here.

9. Tennyson

The Tennyson Electric Fireplace Mantel is an Ivory finished elegant electric fireplace with added bookshelves located either side of the mantel.

This electric fireplace also features great looking flames and an integrated heater. Simply plug in the fireplace, sit back and use the multi-function remote to control the heater and flames.

To see the latest price on the Tennyson Electric Fireplace Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: Southern Enterprises
Style: Traditional
Color(s): Ivory
BTUs: 5000  
Heating Area: 400sqft
Dimensions: 70.25” Width 42.25” Height 14” Depth

  • Adjustable realistic flames
  • Heater with up 400sqft capacity
  • Surrounded by bookcases on either side
  • Elegant and classic design in Ivory color
  • Thermal overload protection

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Easy to assemble
  • Attractive addition to any room
  • Impressed with quality
  • Great for small to mid sized rooms
  • Impressive and practical

You can read all of the reviews on the Tennyson fireplace right here.

Check latest price and buy the Tennyson Electric Fireplace Mantel Package here.

10. Calvert

This beautifully designed electric fireplace mantel finished in Espresso boasts elegant carved moldings along with realistic LED flames and a fan that you can control with a remote.

To see the latest price for the Calvert Electric Fireplace Mantel Package click here.

Specs

Brand: Southern Enterprises
Style:  Traditional
Color(s): Espresso
BTUs: 5000  
Heating Area: 400sqft
Dimensions: 44.5” Width 40.25” Height 14.5” Depth

  • Realistic log set and flames
  • Heater with up 400sqft capacity
  • Beautiful finish in Espresso
  • Elegant moldings
  • Simply plug into electric outlet
  • Flames and embers can be adjusted separately

Verified Buyer Review Comments:

  • Realistic flame and design
  • Attractive and quiet
  • Instantly created a warm feeling
  • Great value
  • Comes as advertised
  • Works and looks great

You can read all of the reviews on the Calvert fireplace right here.

Check latest price for the Tennyson Calvert Fireplace Mantel Package and buy here.

Other Buying Guides

Best Corner Electric Fireplaces

Best Electric Fireplace Logs

Best Electric Fireplace Stoves

Leave a Comment